Politics, Society
Opportunities for Advancement of the Indian Community is Best Provided for by the Barisan Nasional Government
The Indian Community might feel marginalized and left out of the various Transformation Programmes by the Government. How might their fortunes be different moving forward ?
This debate has ended
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : Transformation of Indians has gain momentum since 3rd of April 2009 ,when the Prime Minister DS Najib Razak took over the leadership. The socioeconomic agenda is right direction.
 
2 years, 1 month ago
57 Likes, 23 Dislikes 10 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : State your case
 
2 years, 1 month ago
51 Likes, 21 Dislikes 6 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : I disagree that Indians are marginalised and left out of the various Transformation Programmes. Need to be agreed that prior to 2008 Indians were not given enough attention on their needs. GE12 became (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
47 Likes, 24 Dislikes 19 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : Transformation of indians has not taken place,the Prime Minister has announced some so called transformation programs but are all mere slogans,eg matriculation for Indian students,supposed to be 1500 (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
30 Likes, 49 Dislikes 17 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : Before 2008 why were Indians marginalised?The Prime Minister is only interested in getting the Indian votes.All the transformation announcements have not brought real changes to the man in the street, (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
27 Likes, 49 Dislikes 11 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : MIC will ensure what ever promised be delivered. Just to enlighten you on the issue, so far 900 students have been given seats. The balance seats for 600 students to be settled soon. As you would be a (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
48 Likes, 14 Dislikes 24 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : i am not being impatient on this issue Dato,we can't be faulted if we are frustrated with the delay when it comes to our community,initially (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
21 Likes, 48 Dislikes 36 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : Your statement on ‘so called care’ is very chicky. 2008 was a lesson learnt by all of us. We do not deny that most Indians were not in the mainstream of development. GE12 was a manifestation of the h (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
49 Likes, 10 Dislikes 4 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : So the PM only started looking at the Indian community from April 2009,but he did not suddenly become part of he Cabinet,he was deputy Pm be (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
17 Likes, 47 Dislikes 2 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : YB, DS Najib held few positions prior being a PM and it was a mandate given by PM at his time. The PM decides. So to accuse DS Najib that he (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
33 Likes, 6 Dislikes 2 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : Our government employment percentage is at 5.7% and we are working to increase to 7.4% to reflect the Indian population ratio. A special implementation task force is constantly working on this agenda. (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
48 Likes, 11 Dislikes 6 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : As a marginalised community why stick to population ratio,we should be given more than our population ratio in all areas,not only employment (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
13 Likes, 48 Dislikes 0 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : If you have overlooked my previous comment, let me repeat it again. We are NOT marginalized but were not in the mainstream of development. (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
33 Likes, 7 Dislikes 1 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : Saudara YB Mano, What is the special mechanism created for Indian development in the four states .Please let us know your blue print and implementation done?
 
2 years, 1 month ago
48 Likes, 12 Dislikes 12 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : Can I conclude that nothing has been done for Indian development based on your refusal to answer my previous question? Dear YB, certain thin (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
30 Likes, 10 Dislikes 3 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : Dato,the 4 states PR has ruled the last 4 years has performed well,Tamil schools have received unprecedented recognition and help financiall (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
13 Likes, 30 Dislikes 3 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : Saudara YB Mano, facts will be more convincing than words. Please state your source and show us the proof.
 
2 years, 1 month ago
29 Likes, 7 Dislikes 0 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : Dato,basically what we are saying is the government should be serious and genuine in helping the Indian community,all Tamil schools should be made fully aided,presently 378 out of 523 are not fully ai (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
16 Likes, 46 Dislikes 12 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : Dato let the 6 schools be built first,again I would say after the bitter lesson learnt in 2008 some face saving and vote getting moves,so da (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
10 Likes, 29 Dislikes 2 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : The first Tamil school built was in Penang Free School in 1816 followed Anglo Tamil School ,Malacca in 1850.Rev Abraham built AngloTamil Sc (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
28 Likes, 9 Dislikes 3 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : Dato,I see that you are very particular about facts and figures but I remember that in the 1950s there were more than 800 Tamil schools,plea (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
8 Likes, 28 Dislikes 2 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : (cont) The government also has increased the intake of Indian teachers for KPLSPM , KPLI-KDC and KDPM-KDC with 407,400 and 200 teachers respectively (updated Dec 2011) Lets us not be heroes of syntaxe (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
31 Likes, 11 Dislikes 8 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : Let me repeat , MIC will ensure what ever promised be delivered. Just to enlighten you on the issue, so far 900 students have been given sea (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
27 Likes, 11 Dislikes 2 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : We will wait and see how the 1500 matriculation place gets filled up Dato.Hope this debate is enough pressure for the government to perform, (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
11 Likes, 28 Dislikes 2 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : YB , you are keep repeating about Matriculation which I have already give my assurance that MIC will make sure all 1500 seat fulfilled. Then (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
27 Likes, 6 Dislikes 5 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : Since 2008 the Pakatan Rakyat(PR) ruled states have made some very significant and meaningful contributions to the Indian community although state government only.In selangor,non muslim places of wors (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
12 Likes, 27 Dislikes 7 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : YB , as I said lets be champions of facts.. Kindly show me the breakdown for each mentioned. Not to be forgotten , include all states under (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
26 Likes, 8 Dislikes 1 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : YB , as I said lets be champions of facts.. Kindly show me the breakdown for each mentioned. Not to be forgotten , include all states under PR not only Selangor. Dont try to sweep it under the carpet (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
26 Likes, 5 Dislikes 0 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : Yes Dato,if you want to be champion of facts answer my questions also,lets talk about facts.1.What did the PM do for Indians when he was dep (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
7 Likes, 26 Dislikes 1 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : I am not sure why are you keep repeating the same issue again and again YB.. And you are being hypocrite by talking about DS Najib only..? (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
25 Likes, 7 Dislikes 1 Comments
2 years, 1 month ago
27 Likes, 10 Dislikes 1 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : talking about blueprints,why must you have a blueprint to uplift Indians,just do what is necessary like what the PR states are doing athough (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
9 Likes, 27 Dislikes 2 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : You have agreed earlier that Indians was not in mainstream development. Suffering from selective Amnesia YB ? But under current leadership w (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
25 Likes, 7 Dislikes 4 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : State your case
 
2 years, 1 month ago
7 Likes, 27 Dislikes 0 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : Today in Free Malaysia Today an article titled "Thiagarajan cannot be Nesa chief.....",I quote what was said,"MIC has done nothing"Ms Saraswathy further said,"Yes,most of the shareholders are MIC memb (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
9 Likes, 27 Dislikes 14 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : It seems that you are keen to talk about the past by denying the fact that BN is transforming and we are better choice for Indians now . Come down from cloud nine and see the issue now YB. Indians are (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
23 Likes, 5 Dislikes 2 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : Dato you said Hindraf distantces itself from PR.Is BN and MIC any closer to Hindraf?You also admit that BN made some mistakes in the past.Th (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
5 Likes, 4 Dislikes 2 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : if you check NKRA result ,the country's crime index recorded a 15.4 per cent drop during the first two months this year -- to 22,596 cases f (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
2 Likes, 0 Dislikes 0 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : LAST BUT NOT LEAST : WHEN YOU CAN HAVE ELECTION MANIFESTOS WHY NOT BLUEPRINT ?
 
2 years, 1 month ago
23 Likes, 6 Dislikes 10 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : Dato,Manifestos are for elections,blueprints are plans which explains how something might be achieved.MIC has blueprints for the Indian comm (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
4 Likes, 2 Dislikes 0 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : DPM just announced allocation of 6 millions for SJK(T) Vivekananda Jalan Templer,PJ ..SJK(T) Vivekananda , Briekfields and SMK Vivekananda Briekfields .. This is happening under the transformation pla (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
22 Likes, 7 Dislikes 9 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : Please do not be obsessed wirh blueprints,what use are blueprints when the UMNO controlled government does not implement the action plans.I (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
4 Likes, 3 Dislikes 1 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : You are denying YB ..UMNO doesnt allow implementation ? PM who is UMNO leader has allocated 180 million for Indian business community .. 440 (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
2 Likes, 0 Dislikes 0 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : Transformation programmes does not mean only giving the community what is already owed and then claim to help.You neglect the community for decades when the community supported you,now since 2008 when (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
6 Likes, 4 Dislikes 1 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : And when we go the PM's office to help a student get her IC so that she can continue her studies,we are attacked by MIC members,you cant do it and you will not let others do it also. Please do not say (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
6 Likes, 3 Dislikes 5 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : YB..pls dont spin here .. The stir in PMO started by PKR.. everyone knows how PKR man ,Murali behaved.. read this : http://bit.ly/MKOK5V I d (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
3 Likes, 2 Dislikes 0 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : No way the BN government can provide opportunities for the Indian community in the real and true sense.So long as we Indians are not recognised as equal citizens in this country the UMNO controlled ci (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
7 Likes, 4 Dislikes 3 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : Your facts are misleading as usual.. it is not EXTRA 1000 seats..and please do not claim credit for other's effort. It is a cheap and poor w (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
1 Likes, 1 Dislikes 0 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : Matriculation issue has been solved. All 1537 students got it and name list will be published soon.. Still want to harp on this issue YB? U yet to produce your facts on what PR has done for Indians as (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
5 Likes, 2 Dislikes 0 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : The DPM announced that it is a one off offer for matriculation,so next year we have to beg again.I am not harping on the same issue.Please g (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
2 Likes, 4 Dislikes 0 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : Amusing. PR has been saying election is near since DS Najib took over the leadership. I wonder what makes PR so fear of transformations brou (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
0 Likes, 2 Dislikes 2 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : Back to the topic .. I have answered that opportunities for Advancement of the Indians is best provided by BN ..with BN Blueprint and implementation done as my proof. Please check it here : www.deva (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
5 Likes, 2 Dislikes 4 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : Again Dato you are harping on PR in the 4 states not realising or refusing to realise that all major instruments of power is being held by t (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
3 Likes, 4 Dislikes 0 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : YB.. You have 1 DCM who has no authority to make any decision and you are proud of that? So far what he has done for betterment of Penang In (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
1 Likes, 1 Dislikes 0 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : Dear Dato,its a shame that you cant even recognise that an Indian has been made a DCM in Penang,this is because of your blind faith to UMN (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
1 Likes, 0 Dislikes 0 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : BN can have any number of transformation programmes for the Indiand but it will not transform the Indian community because there is no political will to really help the Indians in the first place.UMNO (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
3 Likes, 4 Dislikes 0 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : We , in BN has admitted our mistakes and moving forward towards betterment. PR is keep harping on 50 years story. You can deny that nothing has changed but the Rakyat is feeling the effect of transfor (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
2 Likes, 2 Dislikes 10 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : Dato,you lament that I am harping on 55 years of BN failure,why?the truth always hurts Dato.We need to look at the past,we simply cannot for (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
2 Likes, 1 Dislikes 3 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : dear Dato,you have been asking me about what PR has done in the PR states,(4 states since Perak was robbed from us by undemocratic means).I will start with Kedah first,for the first time in history th (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
2 Likes, 1 Dislikes 0 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : In Kedah we have now 124 Indians in Ketua Kampongs.Compare this with 13 only under BN!The state govt has paid RM500,000.00 welfare payments to Indians,computer labs to Tamil schools under Titian Digit (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
2 Likes, 1 Dislikes 0 Comments
Manogaran Marimuthu : Dato,you will dismiss the Kedah PR performance as trivial because you always wrongly compare federal capacity with state capacity or refuse to acknowledge the difference.We in PR want and will do the (...)
 
2 years, 1 month ago
2 Likes, 1 Dislikes 0 Comments
Devamany S.Krishnasamy : You are argument are not constructive and productive YB... we are talking about the advancement of Indians best provided by who?. If you say PR, tell us why ..I have shown you my figures on why I say (...)
 
2 years ago
0 Likes, 0 Dislikes 0 Comments

ABOUT iPidato:

iPidato is an online debate network for people who love debates and love to debate. Sign up now and get in on the action.
Opportunities for Advancement of the Indian Community is Best Provided for by the Barisan Nasional Government
FOR
Like
Dislike267
Results of this Debate
Points: 3464
WINNER !!!
 
AGAINST
Like
Dislike611
 
Points: 1911
 
Debate Rating
Debate Rating: 150 Points